2

ONE SET PER EXERCISE?

LOTS OF CONTROVERSY

When I began “pumping iron” at age 18, the best advice I got was to do 3 sets each of about 5-6 different exercise movements. This program worked best for me. I had experimented with more sets and even more exercises, but cutting back a bit produced better results. My program was to work out 3 times per week or every other day (3.5 times per week).

My goal was to be fitter and to be more functional in sports. Very serious bodybuilding (working out for hours, shaving body hair, applying oils and posing) was of no interest to me. To each his own.

Later, I learned about split routines, such as:

  • Upper body one day, legs the next
  • Pushing exercises one day, pulling the next
  • Resistance one day, cardio the next

I also became acquainted with working “to failure”, or doing one set and stopping only when I could not physically lift or pull any more. At times, this would be accompanied by “forced reps”, which meant that a workout partner would help me on the final reps. For example, he might place his hand under the bar to slightly assist on a heavy bench press.

Working to failure was a principle of Nautilus and its founder, Arthur Jones. I used Nautilus machines for several years and later used machines that were somewhat similar. Nautilus programs included negative reps after the positive ones and even instead of the positive reps at times.

A “positive” rep is best described as lifting or pushing something, while the negative aspect is to lower the resistance slowly or to otherwise return to the starting position. It was even said by Nautilus proponents that the negative part was more valuable in strength building.

I can remember constant conflict between Nautilus proponents vs. those who preferred free weights. It seemed to me that everyone wanted to espouse their own methods vs. anyone else’s. Thus, a newcomer might easily get caught between “experts” of opposing workout philosophies. And these “experts” seemed quite unwilling to grant credence to differing viewpoints. Where was the moderator ? The one who might say to a beginner “Do some push-ups, crunches and squats, then go outside for a nice walk. Then we will discuss your needs”. In other words, simplification.

Steve Reeves, perhaps the greatest bodybuilder of all, would work out his entire body 3 times per week. He primarily used free weights – no performance enhancing drugs. I suspect that his methods are rarely used today by professional bodybuilders. Steve is shown below.

SETTING GOALS

The first step in setting up a routine is to clearly establish our goals. We may be:

  • Young and anxious to pack on muscular bulk
  • Overweight and seeking a trimmer body
  • Preparing for a sport, professional or amateur
  • Seeking greater strength
  • Trying to maintain flexibility and fitness as a senior

Here are a few suggestions:

  • For endurance, do at least 12 reps per set
  • For muscle building, do 6-12 reps per set
  • For strength, do 1-5 reps per set
  • Start with 1 set per exercise
  • Consider high reps and sets for cardio (cut back on rest time between sets)
  • Consider each muscle group – chest, shoulders, arms, back, abdominals, thighs and calves
  • Gradually add sets to body parts that may be lagging
  • Keep it simple

STATING THE CASE FOR ONE SET PER EXERCISE

I had recently been doing high reps per set, especially for my core – for example, 2 sets of 100 reps of crunches. This was becoming less than inspiring. I was not looking forward to grinding out all those reps twice.

It began to seem more beneficial to cut back to one set for these reasons:

  • I wanted to freshen my attitude
  • One set enabled me to work to failure, or at least closer to failure – I could go all out
  • One set allowed me to add other exercises
  • My workouts became more intense, though faster
  • My reps improved in quality
  • I could get at least as good a “pump”
  • Rest or recovery time increased. This is when muscles actually grow.

I remembered the words of Nautilus founder Arthur Jones, who said that a good workout set should be more like a rifle shot than a shotgun approach.

Please note- I don’t favor one set over multiple sets except as a change in my current workout schedule. There is plenty of published guidance to support multiple sets per exercise. But, if one set is done to failure, there seems to be little reason to then do another one or two. This is the essence of High Intensity Interval Training.

Above all, please be open to differing workout routines that have worked successfully for others.

RESOURCES

There are many sources of resistance for home workouts. First, here are a few from Amazon. (As an Amazon affiliate, I may earn from qualifying purchases). Check the links and scroll around for other options.

Save Up To 50% On This Week’s Deals at Dick’s Sporting Goods.Dick’s Sporting Goods has been my favorite resource for workout, tennis and golf equipment, as well as sportswear. The link provides access to their entire inventory, with discounts noted.

Bullworker products provide unique and high quality resistance equipment for home use. “Bullworkers” offer the capability for both isotonic and isometric movements. Their link takes you to their company website.

Finally, here are a few options for general health and fitness:

  • FitTrack – featuring the Dara scale, which monitors and reports on 17 important body metrics
  • Flat Tummy – supplements, accessories and apparel for women
  • FitBit – high quality trackers and smartwatches
  • Garmin – maps and smartwatches
  • GOLI – apple cider vinegar gummies for weight loss

CONCLUDING

It seems to me that workout advice can often become too doctrinaire and too stubbornly offered. There are many ways and means to become fit or to otherwise improve one’s health. It is important to experiment with exercise forms in an effort to know what works best for us individually. Most routines will produce good results. Even the very basic – push-ups, crunches and taking a walk.

I would recommend doing some form of exercise daily. The American Heart Association recommends 150 minutes of aerobic activity per week or 75 minutes of vigorous activity. In addition, we should include at least 2 days of concentrated resistance activity per week.

A fitness lifestyle is addictive. We may feel guilty if we miss a day or wake up with little energy. But there is nothing difficult or expensive about exercising our muscles or moving our bodies. And the rewards are plentiful!

Please leave me any comments or questions in the “Comments” section below. Or email me, richard@myworkoutathome.com.

Be well!

      Richard

      2 Comments

      1. I really enjoyed your article Richard as throughout my life I have tried a few different exercise techniques. I agree that some people want to push their training ideas as the only ones that will work but really it all works to some extent if you actually do it. Making it complicated and too hard puts most people off. When I was a teenager I was a lady jockey so I was very fit and strong from working the horses and cleaning stables. When I left racing (way too dangerous) I made a commitment to stay as strong and fit throughout my life and joined a gym to do weights. This led to doing body sculpting competitions and lots of weight lifting to get the sculpting. It was called super setting, 3 lots of 6 reps x 3 days a week and it really worked. I’m still following that program at home with my small barbell and floor exercises with Tai Chi for stretching and walks for cardio.

        This system really works for me even now and also on tired days.

        • Hi Lily! Quite ironic – I also do super sets on occasion and should have included this in my post. This morning, I super – setted my biceps (dumbbell curls) with my triceps (dumbbell extensions) for a good arm pump. This requires less weight, but it is a great technique. Also, it fits in with my theme of using one set. Thanks for your input and I hope you stay in touch!

      Leave a Reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *